Estimated Reading Time: 3-4 minutes
Table of Contents
- Why the Alleged Victim Cannot Drop Your Charges
- Why Prosecutors Refuse to Dismiss
- Can the Case Go Forward Without the Alleged Victim?
- What Not to Do While Your Case Is Pending
- How a Defense Attorney Can Help
- Talk to The Law Offices of Daniel J. Miller About Your Charges
Virginia law allows a prosecutor to continue your case after the alleged victim asks to drop the charges. If you are in this position, you are likely confused and frustrated, especially when the person who accused you no longer wants to move forward.
It’s important to realize that the alleged victim does not control a criminal case in Virginia. The prosecutor does. Knowing why, and knowing what to avoid while your case is pending, can help you protect yourself.
Why the Alleged Victim Cannot Drop Your Charges
Virginia treats a crime as an offense against the Commonwealth as a whole, which is why criminal cases are styled as the Commonwealth against the defendant. The alleged victim is a witness, not a party to the case. Once charges are filed, the Commonwealth's Attorney decides whether to proceed, negotiate, or ask for a dismissal.
Even a prosecutor who wants to end a case sometimes needs the court's approval. Under Virginia Code § 19.2-265.3, a nolle prosequi, the formal decision by the Commonwealth to stop pursuing a charge, is entered only in the court's discretion and only when the Commonwealth shows good cause. The alleged victim can tell the prosecutor what they want, and the prosecutor can weigh that wish, but the prosecutor is not required to follow it.
Why Prosecutors Refuse to Dismiss
Prosecutors know alleged victims sometimes change their position because of fear, family pressure, or financial reliance on the person charged. For this reason, a request to drop charges rarely ends a case on its own. In matters involving domestic violence, assault, or threats, the Commonwealth also weighs the safety of the alleged victim and the community. Prosecutors are less likely to stop when they believe the evidence can support a conviction without the alleged victim's cooperation.
Policies differ from one locality to the next, and some offices are stricter than others for certain charges, though.
Can the Case Go Forward Without the Alleged Victim?
Sometimes a case can proceed even without cooperation from the alleged victim.
The Commonwealth can look to evidence beyond the alleged victim's testimony, including:
- Body camera footage
- 911 recordings
- Testimony from responding officers
- Photographs of injuries or property damage
- Medical records
- Statements from other witnesses
Whether the Commonwealth can use this evidence without the alleged victim on the witness stand is a separate question. The answer depends on the rules of evidence and your constitutional right to confront the witnesses against you. A recorded statement is not always admissible, and a case built around an uncooperative witness can be far weaker than the prosecutor expected. Finding those weaknesses could become a core part of your defense.
What Not to Do While Your Case Is Pending
When charges are pending, you should not contact the alleged victim because:
- Bond conditions or a protective order can prohibit any contact. Violating those terms can lead to new charges and the loss of your bond.
- Virginia Code § 18.2-460 makes it a crime to knowingly obstruct a witness or to use threats or force to intimidate one, and prosecutors can point to repeated contact as evidence of pressure.
- Texts, calls, and social media messages can become evidence against you, even when your intent was kind.
- Asking family members or friends to reach out for you carries the same risk.
If the alleged victim wants to share their position, your attorney can raise it with the prosecutor through proper channels.
Defense Attorneys Can Help When the Prosecutor Won’t Drop a Case
A criminal defense attorney can put the alleged victim's position in front of the prosecutor in the right way and at the right time. From there, an attorney can negotiate for a dismissal, a reduced charge, or an alternative resolution, and can review the Commonwealth's evidence to challenge anything the court should not allow. When the Commonwealth refuses to move, an attorney prepares your case for trial.
Each of these steps should be started before the prosecutor's position solidifies, if possible. Waiting to see whether the alleged victim's request succeeds on its own can cost you time you cannot recover.
Talk to The Law Offices of Daniel J. Miller About Your Charges
At The Law Offices of Daniel J. Miller, we defend clients across Virginia against assault and battery, domestic violence, and other violent crime charges, as well as theft crimes, stalking, white collar crimes, and other crimes that involve a specific potential victim. With more than 25 years of practice experience, our team knows how prosecutors weigh an alleged victim's wishes and what it takes to hold the Commonwealth to its burden. We keep our phone line open 24/7 because charges do not follow business hours.
If the Commonwealth is moving forward with your charges in Virginia, call The Law Offices of Daniel J. Miller at (757) 267-4949 or contact us online to schedule your consultation.